‘For me, it’s garbage’: This Florida man used the repair shop his car insurance company suggested — but his bright green convertible was damaged even more. Here’s what happened

How did State Farm respond?

After waiting five months for the repair, Then feels like he’s now left with a completely different car. The hood, which originally opened with one button inside the car, was replaced with two buttons on the car’s exterior. Then says he's worried the hood isn't secure.

“If you’re going more than 65 or 70 mph, it shakes a little bit,” he told El Khoury.

Frustrated, Joe contacted his State Farm claims adjuster several times but says nothing has been done.

"Nothing is moving because State Farm gives you the runarounds,” he said. ”They tell you we’ll have somebody call you, and nobody calls you.”

Then initially took his car to Gerber Collision and Glass because it was part of State Farm's Select Service program. He was told he could take the car to a shop of his choice, but if repairs were not done correctly, State Farm wouldn't help him.

According to State Farm, this program offers a guaranteed completion date and a lifetime warranty from the shop.

When ABC Action News contacted State Farm, the company provided an email statement. The company insists it does not require customers to use specific car repair shops and doesn't guarantee the quality of work from those shops.

However, they did offer Then an additional $2,600 for his disatisfaction. Gerber Collision and Glass offered no comment.

Stop overpaying for home insurance

Home insurance is an essential expense – one that can often be pricey. You can lower your monthly recurring expenses by finding a more economical alternative for home insurance.

Officialhomeinsurance can help you do just that. Their online marketplace of vetted home insurance providers allows you to quickly shop around for rates from the country’s top insurance companies, and ensure you’re paying the lowest price possible for your home insurance.

Explore better rates

Know your rights as a car owner

To protect yourself, it's important to know your rights, which can vary by state. According to Mark Friedlander of the nonprofit Insurance Information Institute, Florida law protects drivers with specific rights related to the repairs of your vehicle.

“You have a right to get a written, itemized estimate. You have a right to inspect all parts that have been replaced,” Friedlander told ABC Action News.

Additionally, he emphasized the importance of contacting your insurance adjuster as soon as possible if you believe the repairs weren’t done correctly.

“Your insurer is responsible for your car getting back to its original condition,” he said.

There are other steps you can take to avoid similar situations. You can start by reviewing your policy and state laws. Some insurance policies may require you to use specific repair shops, even though state law might say you should have a choice.

Document everything. Keep detailed records of the quotes, repairs, and any conversations you have with the repair shop or your insurance company. Take before-and-after photos of repairs so you can prove what exactly went wrong.

Finally, don't be afraid to escalate the situation. If you aren't satisfied with the quality of repairs, keep pushing for answers and have the vehicle restored to its original condition.

Though State Farm did eventually offer Then additional compensation, he said he’s still not satisfied. He wants his car in its original condition — and a little more peace of mind.

“I don’t want this to happen to anybody else,” he told ABC Action News.